The new series starts tonight. ;)
whoopee! ::)
What a treat tonights show was!! Fun, plain fun, especially when they met to vote. Some people must not watch survivor before they head off to play. One of the few times the person I wanted to see off from the start did herself in. Proves that some people just can't keep their mouth shut. To vote off one of the strongest members would have been total suicide even if Rob is the one to beat.
Hope the rest of you fans liked it as well as I did.
It definitely started off with a BANG! The Federal Agent dude is like the fisherman from the last season, he is self destructing from the git go :). The lady that found the idol right off is interesting, but she will not be around for too long I suspect. She did make a splash though.
I don't see that the two veterans can make it, but who knows?
Different strokes........
Some of us don't watch because we know it's rigged. However, it's entertainment, so if you like it, enjoy enjoy!
America is a great place because of free will :D.
This thread was started for those of us that like the show. For those of you that don't we'll try not to dis your interests.
They need to get rid of the "special agent" asap. What a nut.
If he was a special agent, I'd bet he got kicked out.
I guess we'll find out if it is true later on.
Can you imagine getting stuck on an Island with that weirdo.
The lady who found the Idol isn't as brilliant as the move finding the idol was, as it turns out. :D
Boston Rob and Russell have jumped the Shark for me.
I would be okay if I never heard tell of either one again. ;D
I don't have a TV so I never watch it. But I do enjoy the play-by-play here on the forum. I don't actually know what's going on, but it's fun to "listen" to what everyone has to say.
Each team needs strong physical players until the merge, so I see the old guys staying for a while. Just before merge is when R&R will be in most danger of being voted out. But even when voted out, there is redemption island. Will there be an R&R matchup on RI?
I predict that you can count on it.
I promise not to mention another disparaging word, and I, too , will simply enjoy your exuberant ethusiasm.
With that kind of attitude, we need to get you in on the grits discussions :D.
I agree with both doctorb and jeff. I do not watch the show but like I once told a co worker that liked golf if everyone liked to do what I like to do there would not be room for me. Enjoy
This is much more exciting than last season's snooze fest. These people have spunk!
That was one of the more riveting tribal council's we've seen in a long time. Secret Agent Man doesn't have much self control. :D
I love to watch Rob and Russell work their manipulative magic, and Redemption Island just might be the icing on the cake! Both tribes had shelter in record time, and I didn't see any slackers. Russell's team really did a fantastic job in the Immunity Challenge.
I can't wait till next Wednesday! 8)
I currently don't have TV reception, so I can't watch any current stuff.
The last Survivor Season I watched was in 2004, Season 9 – Vanuatu. My first cousin, Twila, was a contestant on the show and took second place. That season was fun to watch.
There is a lot of secrecy that is required of the participants. What I remember her telling me was, she couldn't even let anyone know she was filming the show until she returned from Vanuatu and then didn't talk about the experience until the winner was announced.
How many of you Survivor fans out there remember her or that season? Nice comments only please - she's my cousin.
Below is an image of the DVD cover from Season 9 (Twila is in upper right corner) and to the right is a photo taken of Survivor contestant Twila and myself at a family gathering.
(https://forestryforum.com/gallery/albums/userpics/20112/3297/Survivor_Vanuatu.jpg) (https://forestryforum.com/gallery/albums/userpics/20112/3297/Dean_and_Cousin_Twila.jpg)
I suspect Mr Federal Agent works for the TSB at a airport checking bags. He did mention he had worked for 3 different agencies. Wonder what the other 2 were, IRS, Purchasing, dunno.... I don't think it was the Secret Service. Seems every season there's always one I want to just reach in and ........ He's it this year so far but ol Russell.......
One of them guys Steve the tall gray haired one was a NFL QB I think. I even would say he was a Raider 2nd stringer at one time.
Sure is a better looking lot than the last ones. I miss Natalie though. I also noticed they are already having water on the lens issues. ;)
What makes people run their mouth when they find the idol? Great move finding it then blows everything by telling dummy 1 and 2.
I have hopes this year.
I remember Twila! She was feisty as I remember. :)
We chose not to keep a satellite when we moved here a couple of years ago, but Sarah and I both enjoyed every series before that. The last few haven't caught my attention much and I was just as glad we couldn't watch them, but this one is, after I read an article on the new aspects. I may have to find it somewhere and catch up!! :)
ErikC, you can catch up on the previous episode at the CBS Survivor website.
I'm just not sure how many days after the first airing before they put it up but it is usually less than a week.
This one is shaping up to be an interesting series. It looks like Boston Rob, the "Intimidator", has gathered enough weak followers to insure that he is around for a while. It's hard to question his strategy. Looks like some of the others are trying to out dumb each other.
it looks better than the previous one, but I am a sucker for this type of TV anyhow...
Quote from: Jeff on February 17, 2011, 04:09:33 PM
I remember Twila! She was feisty as I remember. :)
Yes Jeff, you remember her correctly. I'm glad someone did.
I know we are stirring the conversation to "How do you like the current season". But, I still wanted to comment to Doctorb's statement about the show being rigged. She never felt like the show was rigged. I do think the program/plan/competitions are dynamic, so that things don't get boring for the viewers. No comment required - that way I didn't high jack the thread.
Question for Survivor fans: As stated in and earlier post above, I do not get/pay for TV reception, but we do watch TV via DVD purchases.
The past Survivor Season DVD's are available for purchase. If I was going to buy just one to watch. Which Season would all you Survivor fans purchase? I have seen Season 1-4 and season 9. I haven't followed the show for the past few years and do not know the outcome, so no review spoilers please.
Thanks, Dean
I would have to say Samoa season #19 and Heroes vs. Villains season #20
If you never saw him play, and have to make a choice of seasons you need to watch the ultimate villain Russel.
I completely agree with Jeff and if you have to narrow it down to one series, for me, it would be Hero's versus Villains. You'll see the best of the best in that series.
Jeff-I'm with you on both: Which season to buy? "Heroes VS Villains", and the ex-federal agent needs TO GO! NOW!
I don't think Russel or Boston Rob will make it to the end, but who knows? With the new Exile Island twist, that could shake things up considerably.
It's always a good idea to have the most disliked person sitting next to you at the last vote. Special Agent sure falls into that category. But...oh-my-God! There HAS to be others that are disliked, but not that obnoxious. But Gees....SHUTUP already!! No wonder he's not a special agent any more!! Oh yeah...I'm takin' my foot ball and goin' home. And by the way...Mary took an extra candy last night....so NYAH!
:D That's a very good characterization.
The Secret Agent Man is history :).
I think the secret's out.
Thanks for the suggestion on which seasons are the best. Currently Amazon doesn't show season 19 as an option, but shows season 20 as an option, but not yet released. Most likely season 20 will be released late spring. I will watch for it and I am still open to other season suggestions.
Dean, if possible I would watch season 19 before season 20. I think Russel will make more sence that way.
I liked watching Russell.
I haven't watched the current season yet. I'll have to catch up with it on the internet. Sounds interesting.
Quote from: Carpenter on February 23, 2011, 12:12:54 AM
Dean, if possible I would watch season 19 before season 20. I think Russel will make more sence that way.
I liked watching Russell.
I haven't watched the current season yet. I'll have to catch up with it on the internet. Sounds interesting.
I was a little unclear on the Russell thing. Thanks for the suggestion, I will look for season 19 and go from there.
Quote from: Dean186 on February 23, 2011, 12:15:58 PM
Quote from: Carpenter on February 23, 2011, 12:12:54 AM
Dean, if possible I would watch season 19 before season 20. I think Russel will make more sence that way.
I liked watching Russell.
I haven't watched the current season yet. I'll have to catch up with it on the internet. Sounds interesting.
I was a little unclear on the Russell thing. Thanks for the suggestion, I will look for season 19 and go from there.
Agreed Russel is best enjoyed from the beginning.
I thought some of the characteristics of a federal agent are:
1. Very secretive. They only tell you what they want you to know and only if it will benefit them or their assignment.
2. Low profile. Spend more time listening than talking. Given the chance, most people can not stand a vacuum in a conversation and they will start talking just to make noise. Then they usually say something they shouldn't have. A good agent capitalizes on this.
3. Denial. Always claim to be something other than an agent unless there is a need to identify themselves.
Maybe I've been reading too many books. Or maybe there is a good reason this guy was a federal agent. :D
Another blindside Matt got the boot!! ;D
I would have kept him and kicked his girlfriend off. He was a physical player for the challenges.
Russell is probably going to regret flat out lying to Ol Rooster about the hint. At least I hope so.
Matt getting the boot WAS a surprise.
Secret agent man still needs to GO! AND QUICKLY, TOO!
Let's see how O'l Rooster plays his secret immunity idol. Can he keep his mouth shut? This series has huge potential to be quite entertaining. Has Russell met his match? Agent man could go to the final. Would any jurist vote for him? This show can go in 30 directions.
I may need to reevaluate the Agent man.
Quote from: mrcaptainbob on February 19, 2011, 12:04:36 AM
... No wonder he's not a special agent any more!!
Quote from: iffy on February 23, 2011, 01:55:39 PM
I thought some of the characteristics of a federal agent are ...
So is he a "federal agent" or a "special agent"?
One of my high school classmates became a cop after graduating. When I met him at a class reunion 15 years later, he handed me a business card that showed his official title as "special agent". Turns out after 10 years with the police, he got hired away to an insurance company to do fraud investigations. Not what you might think of as a "special agent" :D.
Quote from: Brucer on February 25, 2011, 01:33:48 AM
Quote from: mrcaptainbob on February 19, 2011, 12:04:36 AM
... No wonder he's not a special agent any more!!
Quote from: iffy on February 23, 2011, 01:55:39 PM
I thought some of the characteristics of a federal agent are ...
So is he a "federal agent" or a "special agent"?
One of my high school classmates became a cop after graduating. When I met him at a class reunion 15 years later, he handed me a business card that showed his official title as "special agent". Turns out after 10 years with the police, he got hired away to an insurance company to do fraud investigations. Not what you might think of as a "special agent" :D.
Oh he's special alright. :D He keeps saying Federal Agent. I still think he worked at a airport frisking passengers or checking bags.
He has said Federal Agent, he has also said special agent, and then this past week, he talked about "wearing the uniform"
Is a straight jacket a uniform smiley_headscratch ???
I don't think that Boston Rob thought about redemption island before booting Matt off. If he wins there and comes back it could bite Rob in the butt.
I would love to see Redemption Island end up with Russell and Boston on at the same time!!! It is possible! Now THAT would make for some great TV!!
Half of your wish has been granted.
Last night was one of the best episodes ever! These people know how to play the game, and it sure isn't boring. Throwing the challenge to force Tribal Council was a stroke of brilliance. Now, Russell goes up against Matt (and the winner goes up against anyone else that get's voted out before the merge) at Redemption Island. Wow. Matt is the nice guy and Russell the ultimate bad boy.
This season is great! 8)
Actually, I think I'd rather see Russell and Ralph on Redemption Island. :D
I agree.
Here's the question: Who will win the joust on Redemption Island-Matt or Russel? ???
Russel. Matt could barely tie two sticks together.
My $$$ is on Russel, too.
It is interesting that Russell did not align better with more than the two girls. The persona displayed on camera was one of bravado. He may think that he is as good as his reputation.
I may change my mind later, but this is the first time I'm pulling for a winner. I would really like to see Ralph get the money.....
Jeff never asked if anyone wanted to play a idol last week even though Ralph had one.
I always thought they should ask until after the vote anyway so nobody knew who had what.
Bill, it may have been edited out.
So they finally did it! Can't believe he is gone.
I had been thinking Ralph was a lot smarter than he lets on because he kept mum about the idol. I don't know why all the players feel the urge to tell someone else when the find the idol.
I guess that they are scared that everyone will be po'ed at them if/when they find out later. I'd be surprised if Rob tells.
I don't think Rob will tell.
I was totally shocked that Russ lost last night! Still can't believe it, getting defeated by Matt.
I don't know why the idiots always feel the need to share their idol secret. It usually comes back to bite them in the end. Rob has the right idea of keeping it to himself if he was to ever find one.
They are just following the script. ;)
When will those idiots realize?? As soon as they vote out the 'other' tribe, they are on the chopping block themselves!! They need to get rid of the snake head. Just can't believe there's so many that drink the kool-aid. Another group that hears chimes when the 'leader' talks....I have to admit, Rob does have a way with words. Very admirable manipulation of people. Okay...I'm off to find me a feather.....
That feather-dude is turning out pretty good. Rob has them paired up so it is harder for them to stray.
The tribe that's on the chopping block only got in that position because they had one less member, one less vote. I wonder if they are rethinking the wisdom of throwing a challenge simply to vote Russell out?
It will be interesting to see who makes it on Redemption Island next week! 8)
Somehow redemption island is going to change the best laid plans.
I'm not a fan of Rob.
Russell is out, but I bet he is laughing. I hope there are some twists and turns to liven things up. Phil is playing as good a game as Rob is. He just might come in second place.
If the losers find an immunity idol, it could really mess things up. It looks like they had to kick two off in one night to get over a slow period.
Glad you brought this back up Cap.
Seems to me the losers missed an absolutely golden opportunity. Rob was paranoid when he found them digging around the flagpole. If they had been thinking, they should have furtively moved off to have a huddle, then pretend to hide something in their clothing. A little slip of the tongue could have convinced Rob's group that they had indeed found a hidden idol, with maybe a hint as to who was in possession. That would have forced Rob's group to split their votes to pull the idol out of hiding, and all the losers could have voted for Rob.
Coulda, Shoulda, Woulda. :)
You're right about that because Rob and Phil were a little frantic about the flagpole.
They could have easily sold it and blew it.
Yep, that minority bunch is not known for crafty moves.
Could be that's why they are the minority.
Can I put my maggot rice in your container of good rice? NOO!!???What do you mean...NO??? What a piece of work. I think his head band's on too tight.
Phil wouldn't get by pulling the race card around here. I thought he might be a cagey player. I have lost all respect for him now and would love to see him get the boot.
This series went from having great potential to "lets get it over with".
Russell would have made it much more exciting for us viewers.
Yes, Phil has freaked out. He lost his shorts ;D.
And he can't get them back,They voted out the only person who knows where they are. :D
I really thought they were going to vote out Phil especially the girls who say he "freaks' them out. Rob sure is a snake charmer.
A lot of that talk is for the camera and those girls are just riding along at Rob's will. I really hope that things perk up and get interesting.
Pretty interesting last night with Mr N word going off like that. Not sure how much interest there's going to be watching him run around in pink skivvies.
It sure has turned into a snooze fest. When they started the puzzle challenge for immunity, I said, "Rob is going to win," and he did. Yeah, what a surprise. ::)
If I hadn't had laundry to fold while I watched, I sure wouldn't have taken the time to sit through another predictable pick off of the Zapatera tribe.
Not a single member of Rob's tribe (including Rob) deserves a million dollars for their game play. Rob is so obvious that he is going to take Phillip to the final three because he knows that no one in the jury will vote for him. The only question left is who that third person will be, and they are all so glassy eyed I don't even care about that.
On a positive note, this season has proven to me that the game isn't fixed, because no way would the producer's choreograph this much boredom into this game.
A very good analysis Roxie. smiley_thumbsup
I guess I'm rooting for Matt.
I think if Matt can make it to the end he will win the money, just because everyone will feel sorry for him being alone all the time.
Quote from: Roxie on April 21, 2011, 08:43:17 AM
Not a single member of Rob's tribe (including Rob) deserves a million dollars for their game play. Rob is so obvious that he is going to take Phillip to the final three because he knows that no one in the jury will vote for him. The only question left is who that third person will be, and they are all so glassy eyed I don't even care about that.
Right now, there are 8 active survivors, 3 on redemption island, and 1 juror. Somethings gotta happen soon. There can't be more than 5 shows left. Typically, they end in a sweeps month, and that would be May. They also have their reunion and final show on a Sunday, and the Sunday before Memorial Day is probably out. Viewership problems.
If there are 5 more voted off, that would give 3 left. The winner of redemption island is going to get back into the game at some point. So, if we have 5 more competitions at redemption island, that puts the jury at 6 member. Add the extra from the island, and the jury gets to be 7 members.
But, the jury is usually 9 members. Speculation on my part, but maybe there are only 2 in the finals. Everyone is suspecting its 3. But, lets say its the winner of the last competition, the runner up, and the winner of redemption island as the final 3. That may be prove interesting.
Good thoughts, Ron. It would be a way to get the third person.....
Finale' is tonight.
Man I'm glad you said something 'cuz I'm sick as a dog over here and I had totally forgotten.
I hope you feel better Logdog.
I am glad this worthless season is over. I will be watching next time though.
Redemption Island was worthless. Hope they don't do that again.
Surely there are more folks like Ralph that want to be on the show.
Matt and a few others were class acts too.
The repeat appearances of former participants hopefully will stop.
Quote from: Mooseherder on May 15, 2011, 08:03:59 PM
I hope you feel better Logdog.
Thanks Mooseherder. I look and feel like a Nyquil commercial over here. I managed to stay awake through the finale though. Rob played a solid game. I'm not really a "fan" of his but he definitely outplayed the others. You know Russell is boiling inside.
Redemption Island is back next season along with two former players :). I don't feel that Redemption Island added any real value to the game.
I agree it's as worthless as Exile Island. The only improvement they made to the show this year was that they didn't send the final three around to pay respect to name plaques of all that were voted off previously. That practice always seemed so phony to me.
After Mike lost at Redemption Island, there was absolutely no one that I was interested in left to win the million dollars.
I could understand why Ashley, Natalie and Andrea didn't vote off Boston Rob, because they knew he had an idol, but, for the life of me, why didn't they go after Phillip?
All in all, the most boring season of Survivor, ever!
Ashley and Natalie must have known that Andrea would have beat them. Natalie provided one of the weakest arguments on why she should win of any finalist in the history of the show.
How much do the runner's up win?
I know everyone get's something but I'm not sure what the scale is.
I fell asleep right after Rob won. Who got favorite player and the $100K?
Boston Rob won the $ Million and the $100K, too.
I vote for all new people next season.
How about they do an episode in the Northwest Territories?
Rob got the extra $100k. I can't figure out how he got to be the favorite. He wasn't mine.
I found this breakdown on one site, but its from back in Australia, so maybe its changed. There are more contestants in some of the years.
1st Place: $1,000,000
2nd Place: $100,000
3rd Place: $85,000
4th Place: $70,000
5th Place: $55,000
6th Place: $45,000
7th Place: $35,000
8th Place: $27,500
9th Place: $20,000
10th Place: $15,000
11th Place: $10,000
12thPlace: $7,500
13th Place: $5,500
14th Place: $4,500
15th Place: $3,500
16th Place: $2,500
Losers also get a nice vacation.
I think next year is Survivor: Baffin Island :D
I thought Matt should have got it just because...........
Did they ever get to the bottom of Phillips Federal Agent status?
Yep. He was one. Worked in the Defense Department and with the Navy. They had a co-worker come on and vouch for his status.
Dumb moves: Getting rid of Russell. Certainly a wise choice, but not when it's two tribes! They diminished their strength when they needed it most. Never EVER throw a challenge to vote one of your off! Second dumb move was all the followers of Rob. Lemmings! Not capable of making their own decisions. Followers will never lead. Rob's group was just the opposite of Russell's. Pitiful!!!
MrC, I completely agree. There are some life lessons on survivor.