The Forestry Forum

General Forestry => Sawmills and Milling => Topic started by: pineywoods on January 21, 2009, 11:04:40 PM

Title: skip the ethanol
Post by: pineywoods on January 21, 2009, 11:04:40 PM
I left my mill idle over the year-end holidays and then a couple more weeks while I battled a case of flu. When I started back up, I heard a loud clank and the motor started running very rough. Shut everything down and started looking. The motor was runnin on one cylinder. This is a 2 cylinder V twin kawasaki that I adapted to my WM LT40 many hours ago. Pulled the valve covers off and found the push rod for an exhaust valve was lying loose in the tube, completely out of the socket on the rocker arm. In the process of putting it back where it belonged, I found the exhaust valve was stuck about half open, looked like probably a bent valve, but after I persuaded upon it with some vice grip pliers, it finally broke loose and popped back up. I called a kawasaki dealer to get information on the proper valve clearance. When I explained what I needed and why, the first thing he said was "are you running ethanol laced gas?" Well, not knowingly, but possibly. He said and I quote " been running a small engine service for 30 years, every manufacturer is having problems with bent valves, bent push rods, broken rocker arms, busted camshafts etc, all attributed to alcohol in the gas. Steel valve stems in an aluminum guide plus alky = corrosion. Let the engine sit idle for a while, and the valve stem seizes in the guide. As long as you run it often, you probably can get away with it but best to skip the ethanol.  I know there are some other forum members running this same motor, but apparently the problem is not unique to kawasaki. Just say no to ethanol >:(
Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: Dave Shepard on January 21, 2009, 11:13:50 PM
I've been running high octane in all of my gas equipment. I've been told that there is no ethanol in the high grades, but cannot verify. Mid grade is a blend of high octane and regular, so I avoid it also.
Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: backwoods sawyer on January 22, 2009, 12:41:21 AM
This last year when gas prices were high the state adopted ethanol, and when they did, they brought it in, in all grades. There was a rash of small engine failures. I went to the wholesaler at the bulk plant after loosing my big saw and a weed eater the same day, and they started ordering in "clear gas" aka "off road gas" all it is, is the old super gas with out ethanol in it. I use it in everything except the cars and trucks. I also add Stay-bil or sea-foam to the tanks of any rig that is not being drove on a regular basis. The ethanol attracts moisture and separates from the gas, so in two cycle engines you are not getting any lubricant. Every logger, fisherman with a boat, and tree service say they lost at least one saw or boat motor to ethanol, before the state would allow the bulk plants to bring in non-ethanol gas from out of state just for non-vehicular use. Seems the governor knew about the ethanol problem with small engines before signing the bill.
Older vehicles that were designed for the old leaded gas should not run on the ethanol either.
Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: cheyenne on January 22, 2009, 01:14:50 AM
Just one more thing the government scewed up.....Cheyenne
Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: Bibbyman on January 22, 2009, 02:39:18 AM
 

(https://forestryforum.com/gallery/albums/userpics/10034/wsbrigsspushrod20081006.JPG)

Here are two push rods out of a B&S 18hp engine.

Briggs twin V OHV problems! (https://forestryforum.com/board/index.php/topic,32839.0.html)

Here is the link to what we went through trying to find out why the engine would not start and what the repair guy said about ethanol. 

I try to put Sta-Bil in all the gas I get for small engines now.
Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: bandmiller2 on January 22, 2009, 05:51:37 AM
Pineywoods,up here in the northeast this is "greenie"central we have everything in the gas except gasoline.I mix a little synthetic 2cyc. oil,and sea foam additive in all my small engine and tractor fuel.What works good is to mix fresh chainsaw mix often then dump the old mix in with the small engine gas.I like syn. because it seems to have no effect on plug fouling and works in low concentrations.Aviation gas is supposed to be pure I have never used it. Frank C.
Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: Larry on January 22, 2009, 12:54:56 PM
I was talking to the coffee shop loafer crowd this morning after reading your post, pineywoods.  One member suggested STA-BIL marine formula.  First time I ever heard of it but most of the marine dealers carry it here along with some Wal-Marts.  My buddy called the factory about using it in lawnmowers and said the recommendation was all small motors...just keep it out of modern cars.  It supposedly solves ethanol problems.

Like I said this was the first time I heard of it so no personal recommendation, but I think I'll give it a try in one of my problem motors.  I've had a lot of problems out of my generator motor.

http://www.sta-bil.com/sta-bil/stabil_marine.htm
Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: Stephen1 on January 22, 2009, 04:01:12 PM
From what I was told it is not so much the ethanol but the moisture it attracts and bonds with. It is the actual moisture that causes the problem if the gas is not fresh. I also use sta-bilzer in all my small engines. On our last long week-end in the summer I buy a big bottle and start adding it to all my gas tanks. I have done this for years and never had a problem(touch wood) with carb fouling or any other over winter problems.
Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: sawmilllawyer on January 22, 2009, 09:21:18 PM
Put Sta-bil in all the small engines around here, have for years. That is of course after my weed eater carb got gummed up with bad gas. The gas stations here are required to post a sign stating that ethanol is in the gas. I don't go to those stations. A certain station advertizes that it sells only pure gasoline, I go to that station for all my small engine gas and for my truck.
Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: srt on January 22, 2009, 10:03:08 PM
On the farm, I had three small engines that had run as recently as August.  I went to start them last Month, and neither of them would run right.  Had to pull apart all three carbs and clean them.  A mess of whiteish "gunk" was in them.   After some reseaqrch online, I also blame the ethanol.  I now put stabil and use high test in everything but the vehicles I drive often.

I spent a couple hours changing out old fule and adding new fule and starting other small engines.  I was unaware you could even purchase gas without ehtanol.  Thanks for the heads up. 
Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: Dave Shepard on January 22, 2009, 11:48:46 PM
Does anyone know if mix oil has any sort of stabilizer in it? I was of the understanding that the professional mix oils did.
Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: ScottAR on January 23, 2009, 12:46:57 AM
I guess if no good gas is available, one could use premix from the auto parts store.
It figures out to about $16.00 a gallon though.  :o

I've been using seafoam in 93 octane gas for my small engines. 
A pint to 5 gallon.  No ethanol gas here yet at least for 93 octane. 

I did learn a few things about fuel a few days ago from a fuel pump rep.
Overdosing ethanol is often a cause for pump failure.  Stations with signs of
"up to 10% ethanol" have been tested for up to 30-40-even 50% ethanol.

Easy way to check is pour a measured amount of fuel in a glass jar.  Let's say 10oz
for easy math.  Pour an equal measure of water in and shake up the jar. 

No ethanol= even amount of water and gas.  If your water level is much greater than
the gas, you have excessive ethanol. 

Also, when buying gas treatment to remove moisture, buy one that has isoprophol
(sp?) alcohol as the main ingredient.  Avoid methanol based products as they are
corrosive to fuel pumps. 

Enough babbling...  HTH


Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: bandmiller2 on January 23, 2009, 06:46:44 AM
Dave,I know Stihl mix oil has stabilzer probibly the better brands do usally they will say if they do.That said I always add a little extra,usally sea foam.Frank C.
Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: bandmiller2 on January 23, 2009, 06:53:54 AM
I've been told the big problem with small engines is their tanks are vented which allows the moisture in the air to be absorbed into the alky.Autos and trucks have sealed systems and are not prone to absorption.What would be good would be a sealing gas cap with a manual vent that could be closed and left between runnings with a full tank of treated fuel.Longer storage drain and run dry.Frank C.
Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: barbender on January 23, 2009, 09:45:27 PM
I always buy the non ethanol premium many stations have available around here, it is labeled as such. I don't like the ethanol in anything, I think I would be better off running premium in our vehicles too (except for my diesel pickup ::)) I tried that E85 in my wife's mini-van for a few tanks (it's a flex fuel) it began to run pretty poorly, I won't do that again.
Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: easymoney on January 23, 2009, 11:37:33 PM
for some strange reason gas sometimes seems to not go bad for a long time. i got a chevrolet van from a cousin about a year ago. it had not been on the road for about 7 years.it had been started about once or twice a year to move it to another resting place. he said he had not put fresh gas in it the entire time. it started with a boost and ran fine.
Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: tyb525 on January 24, 2009, 12:00:53 PM
The Woodland Pro 2 cycle mix I bought from bailey's has stabilizer in it.
Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: Warren on January 24, 2009, 03:14:12 PM
Quote from: pineywoods on January 21, 2009, 11:04:40 PM
... This is a 2 cylinder V twin kawasaki ... 

My dad had a John Deere riding mower with a 20hp kawasaki v-twin.  It dropped or bent a push rod 3 times in the last two years he was alive.  JD dealer kept accusing him of shutting it off at full throttle and causing a back fire.  Never would stand behind the warranty.  After my dad passed away, it went down the road...

-w-
Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: beenthere on January 24, 2009, 04:16:18 PM
Warren
I've had that engine in a Deere lawn tractor since 1996, and never once had that problem.
Nor have heard of it as a problem the 8 years I worked for a Deere dealer.

What model lawn tractor was that?
Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: Warren on January 25, 2009, 04:59:51 PM
Beenthere,

I think it was a 345 hydrostatic with a 48" deck.   At least one occassion when it dropped a rod, I was using it.  And I know for certain with that instance there was no shut off from high throttle, and no back fire.

We have ethanol fuel in our area (40 miles from Cincinnati).  Deere dealer never said anything to us about avoiding ethanol, or putting additives in the fuel. I just assumed it was a bad engine and the dealer wasn't willing to eat it.  After the third trip and $1,800 in total repair bills, and no sympathy from the dealer that there might be something else wrong, it went down the road and I bought a Dixie Chopper Z mower.  Get done in right at 50% of the time, and the purchase price was less than the JD was 5 years prior.  Has a Kolher 27 hp engine.  Have had 3 years with ZERO problems.

Not to diss JD, but that particular unit had an issue.

Warren



Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: shinnlinger on January 26, 2009, 03:09:21 AM
Hi,

What if you had some small engines you suspected you "ethonolaled" in the fall and havent run in a while.   You did the ScottAR water to gas test and found them to be excessive water?  Would a simple drain and replace before running be a sufficient fix, or should you pull a valve cover and drizzle some more oil on the valve stems or something???
Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: ScottAR on January 27, 2009, 12:44:17 AM
Drain tank, change fuel filter, and maybe clean the carb out. 
Oil change wouldn't hurt anything either... 

If somthing don't sound right on startup, start inspecting...

Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: bandmiller2 on January 27, 2009, 06:02:14 AM
A little off topic but close.I've got four older deere 2cyl tractors that used to start first compression but with the newer gas their hard starting and once the plugs get wet game over.Seems theirs no light end to the gas now.Have any of you guys noticed this with your older rolling stock?Frank C.
Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: backwoods sawyer on January 27, 2009, 11:50:36 PM
Well there has been to major fuel changes since that motor was built. They liked the old leaded gas, You take away the lead and add a water absorbing additive to the fuel and they do not like to run the same. Try to find non ethanol supper and that should help. Off road gas for off road vehicles.
Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: Captain on January 28, 2009, 06:40:13 AM
Frank, I would think it is a fuel volitility issue.  Winter fuel (highter volatility) on a warm day any better?

Captain
Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: DR Buck on January 28, 2009, 11:05:49 AM
QuoteMy dad had a John Deere riding mower with a 20hp kawasaki v-twin.  It dropped or bent a push rod 3 times in the last two years he was alive.  JD dealer kept accusing him of shutting it off at full throttle and causing a back fire. 

My Zero-turn with the 25 HP Kawasaki backfires EVERYTIME I turn it off no matter what the throttle is set at.
Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: beenthere on January 28, 2009, 12:54:59 PM
Dr B
Check that the fuel shut-off is working...sounds like it is not.

Should have it if it is fuel injection.
Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: pineywoods on January 28, 2009, 01:26:35 PM
Quote from: DR_Buck on January 28, 2009, 11:05:49 AM
QuoteMy dad had a John Deere riding mower with a 20hp kawasaki v-twin.  It dropped or bent a push rod 3 times in the last two years he was alive.  JD dealer kept accusing him of shutting it off at full throttle and causing a back fire. 

My Zero-turn with the 25 HP Kawasaki backfires EVERYTIME I turn it off no matter what the throttle is set at.

There is a fuel shutoff solenoid built into the carb. Shuts off the main jet when you turn off the ignition. It's probably stuck open with gum left from evaporated fuel or corroded from water in the ethanol.  Look on the side of the carburator.If you see a small wire attached, pull it off with the engine running. The engine should die immediately, if it doesn't the shutoff valve is stuck....
Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: bandmiller2 on January 29, 2009, 05:42:33 AM
Cappy, even in warmer weather the tractors don't start like they used to.They put something in the fuel so it won;t evaporate into the atmosphere as easily.I'll try to find high test without alky and try that .DanG old tractors I don't want to spoil them,they'll want the good stuff all the time.Frank C.



Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: John Mc on January 31, 2009, 02:37:08 PM
The reason that some (not all) high test gas does not have ethanol in it is that when some states were considering mandating ethanol, various groups lobbied to make sure non-ethanol gas was still available. [Some piston aircraft can run on auto gas, but ethanol is definitely prohibited. It's a problem for marine use (ethanol eats some fiberglass fuel tanks, and many boat engines sit longer than cars between use, giving the ethanol more time to suck moisture out of the air). Two cycle engines have a tougher time with ethanol.] Premium gas was picked because it's already something of a "specialty gas" - and because few people run premium in their cars, so making it free stil tended to maximize the use of ethanol-laced gas.

Don't be fooled into thinking that all premium gas is ethanol-free. It's a function of what that state's regs say. And even in some states that allow ethanol free premium gas, they don't necessarily prohibit ethanol in premium gas.

I'm fortunate in my area - even though most gas stations have around 10% ethanol in everything they sell, there are one or two who get their gas from Canada without any ethanol, and a small airport that sells ethanol-free premium auto gas (they don't stock aviation gas). I make a point to buy all my chainsaw gas from one of these sources.

John Mc

Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: Ironwood on February 02, 2009, 12:08:14 AM
One more thing to worrry about ::) Ironwood
Title: Re: skip the ethanol
Post by: Mad Professor on February 04, 2009, 12:39:29 AM
Quote from: Dave Shepard on January 21, 2009, 11:13:50 PM
I've been running high octane in all of my gas equipment. I've been told that there is no ethanol in the high grades, but cannot verify. Mid grade is a blend of high octane and regular, so I avoid it also.

Don't know who told you that but all auto fuel sold in mASSachusetts is "oxygenated", a.k.a. "corn fed" up to 10% ethanol.

Ethanol will react with aluminum or magnesium (more so) so it will also eat up uncoated fuel tanks and carb parts.